I went to University in Vancouver in the late 80's/early 90's. This was when the Soviet Union was still the "Big Bad."
I met my first Communism-apologizers there. Mostly good-natured left-leaning people who truly cared about society, they nonetheless made some strange illogical justifications about the most oppressive regime the world has ever seen. And they all seemed to feed the same ideas back and forth to each other and anyone who questioned or asked them to explain what they meant was politely ridiculed as a "capitalist stooge" who wasn't smart enough to know better. After awhile, the attempted ridiculing wasn't so polite.
And like the bull, that red cape of stupid commentary fluttering in front of me drove me to charge headfirst into every discussion of the so-called merits of the Capitalism vs Communism debate. To the detriment of my social life. Because anyone who attacked communism of course was throwing in with Joe McCarthy.
As my first year room-mate would say: "It's kinda hard to pick up hot lefty chicks if you keep spouting off about the 'Evil Empire'."
"But..."
"Goals, Ray, goals. Do you want to convert them, or fuck them?"
Suffice to say, he got a lot more dates than I did in university. It's easy to get along with hot lefty chicks when you have a rather *ahem* flexible morality with regards to you true opinions (translation: he lied like a used car salesman.)
So little has changed since then. A good friend of my wife and I recently spouted wistful about how she thought it might be better to live in a Communist country...
"What?"
"Well, you know, it's the sense of community, everyone working together, sharing the work..." she trailed off as she saw my face.
"A system with a body count in the tens of millions does not have a 'sense of community'" I stammered.
"I don't know about that," she said.
"Maybe you should do some reading on it..."
"Know any good books on it?" she asked.
I said I didn't, but I've found out that Tacitus does.
There was nothing inevitable about Soviet collapse -- a system that brutalized and slaughtered its own tens of millions need not have crumbled merely because of some economic difficulties.
It takes a long time to grind a country into nothing. Could've taken a lot longer than it did.
The second error commonly committed vis a vis communism is that it's somehow a "noble ideal" that was just executed really, really, poorly. Yep, every single time it was ever tried.
My fellow Canadians who come back from resort vacations in Cuba tell me they had a great time and thought that Cuba was a example of socialism done right. My rebuttal is then why do they want your foreign currency? To finance their crumbling regime, of course. Cubans go to jail for fraternizing with tourists. Hardly a wonderful place to live.
For starters, there's the whole idea that there's no ownership, or that the state owns everything in lieu of private ownership: there's a fundamental contradiction to human liberty right there.
Why are we pouring more money down the sewer in Africa without demanding fundamental reforms? Without property rights, individual Africans can't borrow money on credit for business purposes, can't pass on the rewards of hard work to their children, can't be rewarded for doing a job better than his countrymen might...In another five to ten years there'll be yet another crisis and then another and on and on.
And we (the evil West) are keeping them down by supposedly "exploiting" them. A true capitalist nation would want strong trading nations everywhere so you could sell your products everywhere for top dollar - no one would want Africa to remain the way it is except for the dictators who currently run the show.
This is basic Marx, folks -- the compulsion to turn the wheel of history via the material dialectic -- and it's the justification for concepts like "revolutionary justice," "revolutionary morality," et al. Like all such beliefs, it's a recipe for genocide -- and lo, genocide was done. It's no accident that the greatest mass murderers of human history were mostly communists: Mao, Stalin, Pol Pot, Kim Jong-Il. Communism a noble ideal? Hardly. Communism is murderous racism based on junk economic theory.
And yet many here in this country and in the States make excuses for them.
There's quite an interesting discussion from both left and right perspectives going on in the comments...
Raging Kraut
Whenever someone brings up the "sense of community" thing, you should shoot them down on their own premises. Socialism destroys any sense of community and good will toward one's fellow man. Rand's 20th Century Motor Company in _Atlas Shrugged_ is a decent fictionalization of this. I discuss this a little bit here.
The fundamental problem with communism, is that the basic tenet of communism "everyone works for the betterment of the community", is diametrically opposed to the way humans are hard-wired which is basic Darwinism "survival of the fittest". So even in Mao's China when everyone had to wear the same things, those in the upper ranks of the Party had nice shiny gold buttons on their jackets as opposed to the wooden one the peasants got. They still conveyed a class system, where some people were more important than others.
[Rue] on 01/24/07 11:09 : With bated breath I await your return to blogging. [go]
[Rue] on 01/24/07 11:09 : With bated breath I await your return to blogging. [go]
[Rue] on 01/24/07 11:09 : With bated breath I await your return to blogging. [go]
[Rue] on 01/24/07 11:09 : With bated breath I await your return to blogging. [go]
[Rue] on 01/24/07 11:09 : With bated breath I await your return to blogging. [go]
Gross Display of Most Naked Capitalism
Blogroll
Red Ensign Blogs for Victory!
-- One of the Original Red Ensigns carried by the Penticton 1st Volunteers. It was present at Vimy Ridge when our little Dominion stood up and became a nation worth fighting for...